São Paulo court orders Keeta to drop Pizza Hut brand, daily fine R$50,000

TJSP orders Keeta to remove Pizza Hut trademarks under a R$50,000 daily fine, reversing an earlier ruling and contradicting a November decision that validated intermediated buying.

Wire notes

  • TJSP's 3rd Business Court ordered Keeta to remove Pizza Hut brand assets under a R$50,000 daily fine
  • The ruling awards R$50,000 in moral damages plus lost profits yet to be calculated
  • On 10 November the TJSP validated intermediated buying in an ANR public civil action
  • In January the same court had denied Pizza Hut franchisors an urgent injunction
  • In September the TJSP annulled 99Food exclusivity bans against Keeta
Em nova reviravolta, Justiça de SP barra 'compra intermediada' da Keeta em lojas da rede Pizza Hut
PhotoEm nova reviravolta, Justiça de SP barra 'compra intermediada' da Keeta em lojas da rede Pizza Hut — WOKANDAPIX / pixabay

By Tom Whitfield

A São Paulo court has ordered Keeta, the delivery arm of China's Meituan, to remove Pizza Hut's trademarks, logos and menus from its app within days — or pay R$50,000 per day of non-compliance. The 3rd Business Court and Arbitration Conflicts Chamber of the São Paulo Court of Justice (TJSP) also awarded the Pizza Hut franchisor R$50,000 in moral damages, with material damages for lost profits still to be calculated.

The ruling targets the "compra intermediada" — intermediated buying — model Keeta introduced to Brazil over the past year. Under the format, the platform lists a restaurant's menu without any formal agreement with the owner. When a user places an order, Keeta dispatches a courier to the physical counter to buy the food and deliver it to the customer.

What did the judge decide?

Judge Fabio Henrique Prado de Toledo rejected Keeta's core defence: that its activity was protected by the doctrine of trademark exhaustion, the legal principle barring a manufacturer from restricting the free circulation of goods it has itself placed on the market. The judge found the platform acts far beyond "a simple neutral intermediary providing occasional transport services."

The ruling notes the app "reproduces the names of the chain's restaurants, organises detailed menus, categorises products (...) sets discount values and coupons, processes payment directly in its own interface through proprietary electronic means and charges the consumer a 'service fee'."

In the sentence, the judge concluded: "The unilateral placement of expressions such as 'Intermediada' or the insertion of notices on consent screens (clickwrap) does not eliminate the confusion and improper association."

What evidence did Pizza Hut present?

The franchisors filed notarised records comparing simultaneous orders placed on official channels and on Keeta. The survey showed intermediated buying exposed the brand to lower ratings, fluctuating delivery times, pizzas arriving burnt or cold, and severe disparities in promotional pricing.

The court held that by structuring order capture without consent, Keeta improperly transferred to the pizzerias the burden of operational failures outside the stores' control.

Pizza Hut is not alone. The franchise chains Boali, Giraffas, Greenjoy, Bom Beef Burgers and Pizza Cesar (Grupo Cesar) are among the brands challenging the model. What began as isolated complaints has grown into a wave of extrajudicial notifications and formal disputes over intellectual property and free competition.

Why does the ruling mark a reversal?

The decision reverses the course of São Paulo jurisprudence. In January, the same 3rd Business Court denied an urgent injunction sought by the same Pizza Hut franchisors, reasoning at the time that the model amounted to logistical facilitation that did not constitute unfair competition or improper commercial association.

Less than ten days before this ruling, on 10 November, the TJSP reached the opposite conclusion in a public civil action filed by the National Restaurant Association (ANR), validating the model and denying a request to suspend the feature. In that case, Judge Caio Hunnicutt Fleury Moraes accepted the trademark exhaustion argument, holding that blocking intermediated buying would also hurt establishments that profit from alternative channels.

What happens next?

The legal back-and-forth sharpens the contentious tone of Brazil's delivery market. Keeta and associations such as Abrasel frame intermediated buying as a pro-competitive tactic to break the exclusivity contracts held by large players such as iFood. Franchise networks, in turn, fear erosion of brand reputation built in the digital environment. The inconsistency between rulings is expected to push the debate to higher courts in the coming months.

The exclusivity contracts that motivated the tool are themselves under scrutiny. In September, the TJSP's 2nd Reserved Business Law Chamber annulled contractual bans that 99Food had imposed on the Chinese brand. In parallel cases, competitors have taken Keeta to São Paulo courts and to Brazil's antitrust authority, the Administrative Council for Economic Defense (Cade), alleging unfair competition, partner poaching and inflated subsidies.

In a statement, Keeta said intermediated buying is "a local tool developed as a pilot to expand consumers' access to restaurant options that are not yet integrated into Keeta's platform." The company added: "'Compra Intermediada' exists in a context where the market is blocked by exclusivity contracts that prevent many establishments from freely choosing their delivery platform." Keeta said the model, developed specifically for Brazil, operates in compliance with all applicable local laws and benefits consumers, couriers and restaurants alike.

The takeaway: two São Paulo rulings ten days apart point in opposite directions, and higher courts will now have to settle who controls a restaurant's brand on a delivery app.

via oglobo.com (Source)

Filed under

Share this article:

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in marketing, advertising, marketing technology, media, SEO and search at Marketing Herald.

387 articles

More on the wire

« Previous article