O Globo Editorial Presses Brazil's Chamber to Pass Big Tech Bill
O Globo's editorial urges Brazil's Chamber to rush the Big Tech bill through, backing it with Exeter's Beatriz Kira and the EU's 2022 DMA deterrence record.
Wire notes
- Beatriz Kira of the University of Exeter told O Globo every day of delay in approving the Big Tech bill is a loss for the Brazilian economy.
- The EU approved the Digital Markets Act in 2022; its third evaluation, published in May, found fines have played a fundamental deterrence role.
- The EU, UK and Japan have already enacted digital-competition laws; Brazil's bill remains in the Chamber of Deputies.
- O Globo rejects claims the bill threatens free expression, noting the text never mentions content moderation.
- The editorial says Cade's current legal toolkit is insufficient to police digital competition.

Every day Brazil's Chamber of Deputies delays the Big Tech bill costs the economy, warns jurist Beatriz Kira of the University of Exeter. "Cada dia de atraso na aprovação desse Projeto de Lei é uma perda para a economia brasileira," Kira told O Globo, in an editorial the newspaper headlined as an urgent call for the Chamber to act.
The bill (PL das Big Techs), now moving through the Chamber, targets what the editorial calls a market reality unique to digital: a handful of large corporations dominate online commerce, set their own rules without transparency, and don't always act in society's interest. The practices the bill aims to curb include:
- Privileging the platforms' own businesses in search and ranking
- Raising impassable barriers to competitors
- Requiring protocol-style permission to collect sensitive data
- Applying arbitrary guidelines that threaten the free market
Kira defended the bill's scope as deliberately narrow: "Esse PL tem um critério muito claro de salvaguarda para só capturar os grandes ecossistemas tecnológicos. É uma questão de promoção de justiça da concorrência, de abertura de mercado e inovação. Serão poucas empresas reguladas, com muitas beneficiadas."
What does the international record show?
The European Union, the United Kingdom and Japan have already passed digital-competition laws. O Globo points to the EU's Digital Markets Act, approved by the European Parliament in 2022, as the leading example. The law's third evaluation, published in May, found that fines and penalties imposed under the DMA have played a fundamental role in deterrence.
The editorial lists concrete gains for consumers and businesses under that regime: consumers comparing prices for products, travel or services are less likely to be steered toward suppliers that pay the comparison platforms; they cannot be forced to accept pre-installed software; hotels and car-rental firms can run promotions on their own sites. The DMA has also delivered greater transparency over data collection, more equal treatment in search results, and control over the exorbitant tolls often charged to developers offering their products or services through platforms.
Why do the platforms' counterarguments fail?
In Brazil, digital platforms argue that current law already lets the Administrative Council for Economic Defense (Cade) police digital competition. O Globo calls the argument false: the legal arsenal available to Cade is insufficient, and if it were adequate, the large digital conglomerates would long ago have changed their abusive practices.
A second objection — that the bill threatens freedom of expression — gets shorter shrift. The editorial notes the text contains no mention of content moderation, which is the subject of other legislative initiatives. Blocking the bill on that flag, it says, is playing make-believe.
The bottom line from O Globo: Brazil needs a new legal framework to solve the abuses of digital platforms, and there is no reason for further procrastination in the Chamber. With the EU's May evaluation showing deterrence works, the pressure on Brasília is now squarely on the calendar.
via oglobo.com (Source)
More from James Calloway
Show full bio
Market editor covering technology and product news in marketing, advertising, marketing technology, media, SEO and search at Marketing Herald.
381 articles
More on the wire
- Economists Urge Brazil's Chamber to Pass Bill Expanding Cade Powers Over Big Techs
- Brazilian Right Attacks Big Tech Antitrust Bill as Censorship
- Brazil’s Big Tech bill targets competition, not content moderation
- Brazil's Digital Markets Bill Would Give Cade Power Over Gatekeepers
- 48 groups urge Lula to regulate Big Tech after election