Brazilian Right Attacks Big Tech Antitrust Bill as Censorship
Brazil's Digital Markets bill would let Cade impose ex-ante conduct rules on platforms like iFood and Apple. Right-wing deputies call it censorship — the text never mentions moderation.
Wire notes
- Deputies Mario Frias (PL-SP), Julia Zanatta (PL-SC) and Jeffrey Chiquini (Novo-PR) called the Digital Markets bill censorship
- Brazilian antitrust conduct investigations currently take two to three years
- The bill grants Cade powers modeled on UK and EU ex-ante digital markets rules
- Economist Marcos Lisboa flagged the bill's missing efficiency-gains exception present in UK law

By Amara Osei
Brazil's Digital Markets bill — the so-called PL das Big Techs — contains no provision on content moderation, yet three right-wing lawmakers have denounced it as censorship. Deputies Mario Frias (PL-SP) and Julia Zanatta (PL-SC), plus elected deputy Jeffrey Chiquini (Novo-PR), framed the bill in recent days as a threat to freedom of expression, according to the USP public policy professor who authored the analysis.
The professor calls the association baseless. "A associação não tem pé nem cabeça. Serve apenas como espantalho" — the claim has no legs and serves only as a scarecrow, he writes.
What does the bill actually do?
The bill gives the Administrative Council for Economic Defense (Cade, Brazil's antitrust authority) tools to impose conduct obligations on large platforms. It does not address the moderation of content at any point.
The professor argues the initiative is timely because platforms as different as Mercado Livre, Android and Uber control the conditions under which other service providers operate, and can use that control to favor their own services or raise entry barriers.
Past cases back the concern. The Google privileges its own Google Flights service in flight searches. Apple required use of its payment system for in-app iPhone subscriptions and barred developers from telling users about cheaper options outside. iFood held exclusivity contracts that stopped restaurants from listing on rival apps. In each case, authorities found the platforms' control restricted competition and harmed consumers.
Why current antitrust law falls short
Traditional antitrust enforcement is slow and largely ex post — it acts after damage is done. In Brazil, specific-conduct investigations run two to three years. Modern regulatory models, such as the European and British ones, allow faster, preventive (ex ante) rules that set obligations before competitive harm consolidates.
The bill imports instruments now present in British and European law. Cade could:
- force marketplaces to disclose how they rank offers and bar self-preferencing of their own products;
- require platforms to let users transfer their data to competing services;
- mandate interoperability between messaging apps, allowing users on different platforms to communicate.
Where the legitimate criticism lies
A real technical debate exists — and none of it concerns speech. The bill follows the British model, which identifies firms with strategic positions and imposes tailored obligations, rather than the European approach of broad duties for all large gatekeepers.
In Folha de S.Paulo, economist Marcos Lisboa noted the bill, unlike UK law, provides no exception for conduct that violates the obligations yet delivers efficiency gains benefiting consumers. A review by the Instituto dos Advogados Brasileiros found the text suggests a simple filing by federal government bodies could trigger immediate proceedings against a platform, bypassing the prior technical filter that applies to other complaints.
Those are the open questions. Censorship is not among them.
The professor argues the censorship framing is strategic, not conceptual confusion: since social platforms began resisting content-moderation regulation, the right has treated them as allies in defending unlimited free expression — and now returns the favor by defending their economic interest.
Who does the bill protect?
Drivers in their dealings with Uber and 99; restaurants facing iFood and Rappi; app developers dependent on iPhone and Android. Antitrust regulation, the professor writes, does not limit free competition — it protects it. "É no mínimo estranho que quem se diz liberal se oponha a ela" — it is at least strange that self-declared liberals oppose it.
Whether the bill's missing efficiency defense and weakened procedural filter survive committee scrutiny will decide its credibility.
via oglobo.com (Source)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in marketing, advertising, marketing technology, media, SEO and search at Marketing Herald.
363 articles
More on the wire
- Brazil’s Big Tech bill targets competition, not content moderation
- Brazil's Digital Markets Bill Would Give Cade Power Over Gatekeepers
- Brazil Big Tech Bill Rewritten to Kill Censorship Claims
- O Globo Editorial Presses Brazil's Chamber to Pass Big Tech Bill
- Economists Urge Brazil's Chamber to Pass Bill Expanding Cade Powers Over Big Techs