MH-4275Advertising & Media
EU Court Adviser Moves to Revive €1.49 Billion Google Ad Fine
An EU court adviser wants a €1.49 billion Google ad fine reinstated, weeks after a U.S. judge spared Google's ad tech from divestiture. The Trade Desk's rare revenue decline shows rivals' deeper problem.
Wire notes
- On Nov. 12, Advocate General Juliane Kokott recommended overturning the 2024 annulment of a €1.49 billion ($1.7 billion) EU fine on Google's AdSense for Search.
- In September, Judge Leonie Brinkema rejected the DOJ's proposed divestiture of AdX and DoubleClick for Publishers, accepting behavioral remedies instead.
- The Trade Desk reported a rare Q3 revenue decline of about 0.5%, to $736 million from $739 million a year earlier.
- Liftoff Mobile grew Q3 revenue 32% year over year to $238 million, with $145 million adjusted EBITDA.

A senior adviser to the European Union's highest court has recommended overturning the 2024 judgment that annulled a €1.49 billion ($1.7 billion) fine against Google over its AdSense for Search business. Advocate General Juliane Kokott published her opinion on Nov. 12, arguing the EU's General Court made legal errors when it threw out the European Commission's original 2019 penalty.
Kokott concluded the lower court had imposed excessive requirements on regulators assessing whether Google's contractual restrictions harmed competition. The case concerns agreements Google used with publishers displaying search advertisements through AdSense for Search — a different business unit from the one under scrutiny in Google's most recent U.S. trial.
According to the European proceedings' plaintiffs, between 2006 and 2016 Google imposed contractual restrictions limiting those websites' ability to display advertisements from rival search advertising providers. The Commission identified three types of restrictions:
- Exclusivity clauses preventing publishers from using competing services
- Placement clauses restricting where rival advertisements could appear
- Provisions requiring Google's prior approval before changes to advertising displays
The Commission concluded these practices constituted a single, continuous infringement of European competition law. In September 2024 the General Court annulled the fine, finding regulators had failed to examine relevant circumstances adequately, particularly the duration of Google's contractual arrangements. Kokott argued the court placed excessive emphasis on the duration of individual agreements rather than their collective effect on competition. She recommended setting aside the 2024 judgment and returning the case to the General Court.
What does the opinion change?
Not the fine itself, yet. The opinion is nonbinding, and the Court of Justice has yet to issue its judgment. Kokott also acknowledged the penalty should ultimately be reduced, because certain findings concerning Google's conduct in 2016 are no longer being contested. The practical effect is the prospect of another prolonged legal battle over Google's advertising practices, arriving two months after Google avoided a forced breakup of its advertising technology business in the U.S.
In September, federal judge Leonie Brinkema rejected the Justice Department's proposed divestiture of Google's AdX exchange and the DoubleClick for Publishers ad server. The court accepted most of the government's proposed behavioral remedies, subject to modifications. The decision shifted the focus from Google's ownership of its advertising infrastructure to the restrictions governing how that infrastructure operates. The remedies target Google's ability to favor its own advertising products through interoperability, auction transparency and access for competing ad tech companies. Google has indicated it intends to appeal the underlying liability decision, potentially extending the litigation beyond implementation of the remedies.
What does this mean for Google's competitors?
The European and American cases concern different markets and legal questions, but both illustrate the difficulty regulators face challenging Google's advertising dominance. In Europe, courts are still examining conduct that ended a decade ago. In the U.S., the argument has moved from whether Google violated competition law to whether remedies will materially change market behavior.
The Trade Desk supplied the sharpest evidence that independence from Big Tech does not guarantee growth. On Nov. 9 the company reported a rare quarterly revenue decline: third-quarter sales fell approximately 0.5%, to $736 million from $739 million a year earlier. The result beat Wall Street's modest expectations but marked a sharp reversal for a company long accustomed to double-digit growth, amid competition from Amazon, shifting agency relationships and AI-automated media buying. Heavy investment in the Kokai platform has yet to restore historical growth rates.
On the earnings call, CEO Jeff Green revealed leadership were reconsidering how acquisitions might contribute to the company's next phase of growth, suggesting a more active approach to M&A than The Trade Desk has historically pursued. Regulators may eventually make Google's advertising infrastructure more accessible to rivals. Those rivals must still persuade advertisers their platforms offer better technology, performance and economics.
Numbers to know
Liftoff Mobile's Q3 results:
- Revenue grew 32% year over year to $238 million, from $180 million a year earlier
- Adjusted EBITDA reached $145 million, up 45%, a 61% margin
- Net income was $87 million, against a $6 million net loss in the 2025 period
- Q4 guidance: revenue of $244 million–$249 million and adjusted EBITDA of $150 million–$154 million
Elsewhere, OpenAI is preparing to give brands visibility into how frequently they appear in ChatGPT responses, and its new business agents offer brands a direct route into conversations the company is also selling as advertising. "AI will catalyze the cure for what we call persistent fragmentation in advertising technology," Terence Kawaja, CEO of LUMA Partners, told attendees at the firm's flagship annual conference. Google, meanwhile, is introducing greater transparency around invalid-traffic credits for advertising customers. For practitioners, the week's lesson is that regulatory pressure on Google keeps building — but market outcomes will be decided by performance, not courtrooms alone.
via adexchanger.com (Original)
More from Priya Raman
Show full bio
Correspondent covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in marketing, advertising, marketing technology, media, SEO and search at Marketing Herald.
323 articles
More on the wire
- Google Ad Tech Remedies: A Code of Conduct, Not a Breakup
- Google Keeps AdX as Court Rejects Breakup in Ad-Tech Case
- Publishers Brace for Limited Relief in Google Ad Tech Remedies
- Judge Dismisses Chegg and Penske Antitrust Suits Against Google
- Grindr's $35 Million Data Settlement Anchors a Week of Legal Shocks