Ninth Circuit Weighs Fate of Tegna Injunction in Nexstar Appeal

The Ninth Circuit heard Nexstar's bid to lift or narrow the Tegna injunction, with judges signaling a high bar for reversing the freeze ahead of a July 2027 antitrust trial.

Wire notes

  • Nexstar's $6.2 billion Tegna acquisition remains frozen under a preliminary injunction ahead of a July 2027 trial.
  • Nexstar asked the Ninth Circuit to vacate the injunction or limit it to Big Four stations in 31 DMAs.
  • 13 states and DirecTV defended the district court's hold-separate order at Tuesday's hearing.
  • One judge said reversing would require 'very high confidence that there was a feasible alternative.'
Ninth Circuit Tackles Nexstar-Tegna Injunction
PhotoNinth Circuit Tackles Nexstar-Tegna Injunction — Chronomarchie / pixabay

A federal appeals court heard Nexstar's challenge to the Tegna injunction Tuesday, in a case that will determine how far the broadcaster can integrate its $6.2 billion acquisition before a July 2027 trial.

Nexstar asked the Ninth Circuit panel to vacate the preliminary injunction entirely, or at minimum limit it to Tegna's Big Four stations in the 31 DMAs where the plaintiffs allege competitive harm. The company argued the current order, which freezes its integration of Tegna, reaches well beyond the alleged injury.

Nexstar also told the panel that the district court heard no evidence that keeping all of Tegna separate was necessary. The broadcaster pointed to precedent from the Department of Justice, across both Republican and Democratic administrations, which has accepted hold-separate agreements in broadcast deals.

Deanne Maynard, Nexstar's counsel and a partner at Morrison Foerster, made the DOJ comparison directly to the panel: "The federal DOJ has challenged mergers, making very similar claims to the ones that plaintiffs make here. Indeed, the plaintiffs rely on those consent decrees in convincing the district court that the appropriate geographic market is individual DMAs, and in all those cases, the federal government… has concluded that divestiture of the stations that produce the alleged anti-competitive harm are sufficient to cure the anti-competitive allegations."

What does the injunction fight change for the deal?

The opposing side — 13 states and DirecTV — argued the district court was right to preserve Tegna as it existed before the combination.

Emily Curran, Deputy Attorney General for California's DOJ, pressed on the practicalities of Nexstar's proposed fix. She questioned what the hypothetical 31-station version of Tegna would look like, how it would be structured, and who would oversee it.

Ben Horwich, a partner at Munger Tolles & Olson representing DirecTV, grounded his argument in the 1914 Clayton Act. He said the statute is meant to target transactions that would lessen competition, and that it is not the court's job to figure out how to restructure the deal.

The judges gave no timeframe for a final ruling. But one comment from the bench signaled the height of the bar Nexstar faces. Discussing the prospect of reversing the district court's decision, the judge said: "We'd have to have very high confidence that there was a feasible alternative."

What happens next

For marketers and media buyers, the stakes are operational rather than abstract. A full freeze keeps Tegna's stations, sales teams, and inventory walled off from Nexstar's until at least the July 2027 trial. A narrowed injunction limited to the 31 contested DMAs would let Nexstar begin integrating the rest of the portfolio, consolidating national sales and rethinking station groups years earlier than the current order allows.

The panel's eventual ruling, whenever it comes, will effectively set the clock on how long the combined Nexstar-Tegna footprint remains two companies in practice rather than one.

via cablefax.com (Source)

Filed under

Share this article:

More from Priya Raman

Priya Raman

Show full bio

Correspondent covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in marketing, advertising, marketing technology, media, SEO and search at Marketing Herald.

348 articles

More on the wire

« Previous articleNext article »