Pennsylvania Cable Group Sues FCC Over Repeal of 39% Broadcast Cap

BCAP sued in the Third Circuit to vacate the FCC's repeal of the 39% broadcast ownership cap, warning mergers could close before courts can review them before Jan. 11.

Wire notes

  • BCAP filed its challenge Friday, one day after the FCC order was published in the Federal Register.
  • The FCC order, approved 2-1 in August, repeals the 39% national audience cap and takes effect Jan. 11.
  • BCAP joined nine other state broadband associations in requesting an FCC stay; the Commission has not acted.
  • The Media Bureau approved the Nexstar-Tegna deal in March with a cap waiver.
  • The Third Circuit has not ruled on the petition or set a schedule.
Pennsylvania Cable Group Sues Over FCC Order Scrapping 39% Cap
PhotoPennsylvania Cable Group Sues Over FCC Order Scrapping 39% Cap — This_is_Engineering / pixabay

The Broadband Communications Association of Pennsylvania asked a federal appeals court on Friday to strike down the FCC's order repealing the 39% national audience cap on broadcast station ownership. The filing came one day after the FCC order appeared in the Federal Register.

BCAP petitioned the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit to hold the order unlawful, vacate it, enjoin it and set it aside as arbitrary, capricious, in excess of statutory authority and otherwise not in accordance with law. Without court intervention, the FCC's new framework takes effect Jan. 11.

What does the repeal change?

The FCC's order, approved on a 2-1 vote in August, scraps the 39% cap (the limit on the share of national TV households one owner may reach) and replaces it with case-by-case review of individual transactions. That shift is the core of BCAP's complaint. The association argues mergers approved under the new approach could close before any court gets a chance to review them.

BCAP has already pressed the pause button inside the agency. It joined nine other state broadband associations in asking the FCC to stay the ownership cap order. The Commission has not acted on that stay petition.

Why does the Nexstar-Tegna deal matter?

BCAP pointed to the Nexstar-Tegna transaction as evidence the risk is real. The FCC's Media Bureau (the agency's staff-level licensing arm) approved that deal in March with a waiver of the cap. BCAP then asked the full FCC to review the order. The Commission has not ruled, and the D.C. Circuit held that the court cannot intervene until the full FCC acts on BCAP's pending application for review.

BCAP described the resulting bind bluntly: "In short, FCC believes it can avoid judicial review of mergers indefinitely by directing Bureau staff to approve mergers and then refusing to rule on applications for review, and the only court with jurisdiction over FCC merger orders has held that it is powerless to say otherwise."

The association wants the Third Circuit to stay the FCC order while the case proceeds. Absent a stay, the agency could clear further consolidation deals under the case-by-case standard, and buyers could close them before judges weigh in.

What happens next?

The Third Circuit has not ruled on the petition and has not set a schedule. The clock runs toward the Jan. 11 effective date, so any stay request will test how quickly the court moves. The outcome shapes how much of the broadcast merger market consolidates before the legality of the repeal itself is settled.

via cablefax.com (Source)

Filed under

Share this article:

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering technology and product news in marketing, advertising, marketing technology, media, SEO and search at Marketing Herald.

322 articles

More on the wire

« Previous article