Attention, Not Data, Is Marketing's Real Currency, Says Joe Marchese

Joe Marchese, CEO of Human Ventures Holdings, says attention beats data, AI agents pose a fiduciary trust problem, and brands must invest in what machines cannot optimize.

Wire notes

  • Joe Marchese is CEO of Human Ventures Holdings and co-author of Human Dot AI
  • He founded true[X], built on engaged attention over impression volume, before Fox acquired it
  • His filter: anything machines can understand, they will eventually optimize
  • His book examines how the attention economy shaped the last 25 years of media
Attention Is Still the Currency: Joe Marchese on Brand Building in the AI Era
PhotoAttention Is Still the Currency: Joe Marchese on Brand Building in the AI Era — StockSnap / pixabay

Joe Marchese argues that marketers' decades-long pursuit of better data missed the basic question: did you earn anyone's attention in the first place? The CEO of Human Ventures Holdings laid out that case on The Speed of Culture podcast, and he believes AI has now raised the stakes again.

AI agents that buy on behalf of consumers may soon influence purchase decisions before a brand gets a direct chance to speak, Marchese said. That shift reframes the old problem of trust between advertisers and audiences.

Why data alone fails

Marchese's original thesis at true[X], the advertising company he founded before Fox acquired it, was simple: not all impressions are equal. Marketers could hold enormous amounts of data about a person, but without that person's attention, none of it mattered. Attention alone still creates the opportunity to tell a story.

His criticism of programmatic advertising (automated buying of ad space) is structural. Quality attention was undervalued largely because it was harder to measure than impression volume, he said.

What happens when AI agents recommend products?

Marchese compares AI agents with human agents in real estate, insurance and entertainment. If an agent acts on someone's behalf, the user needs confidence that its incentives are aligned with theirs.

The problem starts when advertising enters the equation. If an AI recommends the product that pays rather than the product that is best, the relationship stops looking like trusted advice and starts looking like hidden persuasion, he argued.

His book, Human Dot AI: How the Fight for Your Attention Became the World's Biggest Business, examines how the attention economy shaped the last 25 years through algorithms that decided what deserved people's time. He calls the next phase more consequential, because conversational AI can build deeply personal relationships with users. His warning: if those relationships are tied to performance or advertising incentives, marketers and consumers need to think carefully about who the AI is actually serving.

Where should CMOs invest?

Marchese offers a sharp filter for AI-era strategy: anything machines can understand, they will eventually optimize. That pushes competitive advantage toward areas that remain hard to automate:

  • Strategy and human judgment
  • Culture and shared narratives
  • Experiential marketing
  • Real-world human connection

For marketers, the question becomes less about outperforming the machine at optimization and more about where human judgment still creates differentiated value, he said.

His investment thesis at Human Ventures reflects the same logic. He points to live events, festivals, hospitality and media tied to real-world experiences as areas of enduring value. Technology can help humans connect, but physical spaces and shared cultural moments create something difficult to replicate digitally. For brands, experiences and sponsorships become more than awareness plays; they become part of the cultural infrastructure around the audience.

Is brand just shared cultural currency?

Marchese rejects the performance marketing idea that every impression outside a narrow target audience is wasted. A brand needs to matter not only to the buyer, but also to the people around them — friends, family, colleagues and wider culture. That shared narrative is part of what makes brand valuable, even when last-click attribution (crediting the final ad before purchase) cannot capture the effect.

The implication for CMOs is direct: as AI agents automate both buying and optimization, the defensible assets will be the ones machines cannot fully measure or replicate — attention, culture and shared experience.

via Adweek (Source)

Filed under

Share this article:

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering technology and product news in marketing, advertising, marketing technology, media, SEO and search at Marketing Herald.

352 articles

More on the wire

« Previous articleNext article »