MH-2194Advertising & Media
Amazon Scraps a 5.8-Star Christmas Ad for a Costlier Bet on Something New
Amazon retired 'Joy Ride', a 5.8-star ad that scored 5.7 on rerun last year, for the new 'Joy Delivered'. Mark Ritson calls the swap a bet against its own proven asset.
Wire notes
- Amazon's 2023 ad 'Joy Ride' scored a maximum 5.8 stars from System1 and 5.7 when rerun in 2024.
- New film 'Joy Delivered' launched earlier this month, set to a Beatles' 'Golden Slumbers' cover.
- System1 tested 50,000+ ads and found scores barely decline with age; some improve.
- Coca-Cola's 'Holidays Are Coming' has run every Christmas since 1995 and always scores five stars.
- Amazon global chief brand officer Jo Shoesmith told ADWEEK consumers want nostalgia plus 'something they haven't seen before.'

By Tom Whitfield
Amazon has pulled its highest-scoring Christmas ad, "Joy Ride", which earned a maximum 5.8 stars from System1's ad testing, and replaced it with a new film that carries more risk and more cost. The decision, argues marketing columnist Mark Ritson, is a bet against the retailer's own proven asset.
The new ad, "Joy Delivered", launched earlier this month and runs like a short movie. Its heroine, Joy, is stuck at an airport on Christmas Eve with every flight cancelled and snow falling hard. She picks up her bag of presents and travels home the long way: a bus, a lift from donkey farmers, a night in a boat cabin on a heaving sea, a taxi driven by a giant. At every stop she thanks a stranger with one of the Amazon parcels meant for her family.
A new version of the Beatles' "Golden Slumbers" carries the emotional weight. "The hug at the end will get you," Ritson writes.
What was wrong with 'Joy Ride'? Nothing.
The film Amazon retired was, by testing standards, near-perfect. "Joy Ride", first aired in 2023, shows three old ladies on a snowy hill watching local kids sled. One orders seat cushions from Amazon; the box arrives and the three fly down the hill, girls again for a few seconds. There is no dialogue, only an instrumental of "In My Life".
System1 scored it 5.8 stars. That is the maximum.
Then Amazon did something unusual for a major marketer. Last year, rather than commissioning a new ad, it simply ran the old one again. "Joy Ride" scored 5.7 on its second outing — again placing it in the rare company of fewer than 1% of all ads made that year.
Why ads don't wear out
The evidence against replacement is decades old. Coca-Cola first ran "Holidays Are Coming" in 1995. The trucks have returned every Christmas since, and System1 says the ad consistently scores five stars in testing.
System1's analysis of more than 50,000 ads found that scores barely move as ads age, and that some of the strongest executions actually improve as audiences get to know them. Ritson's verdict is blunt: ads don't wear out, at least not for consumers.
The average brand-building campaign reaches maximum impact two to three years into execution, he notes. Seasonal work can run for decades, as Coke has proved. The problem sits inside the marketing department.
The marketer is not the consumer
"Marketers forget they are not the consumer," Ritson writes. They review an ad for at least 9,000 hours before release and grow tired of it before most of the target market has even noticed it. The same dynamic applies to slogans, logos and distinctive brand assets.
Amazon's advertising decisions are made by marketers — "people who like to make new, shiny stuff", in Ritson's words. Jo Shoesmith, Amazon's global chief brand officer, told ADWEEK that people want nostalgia but also "something they haven't seen before."
Ritson calls that a complete contradiction.
There is a middle path. Amazon could copy Coca-Cola: rerun the old ad every year and add a weaker new execution alongside it. Ritson dismisses it: "But why create a bat to beat yourself with?" Better, in his framing, to remove an outstanding, already-made, already-free, already-proven, already-loved Christmas ad and run something less good with more risk attached.
A side note on the snow
One peripheral problem: Amazon shot its white Christmas in and around Dunedin, New Zealand, where it is summer — and will be warmer still by Christmas, when most of the country is at the beach in shorts.
The closing argument lands on patience. Marketers routinely demand more CEO support, more budget, more boardroom seats. What they mostly need, Ritson writes, is patience — a good campaign takes years, not months. Amazon knew that last Christmas. It has already forgotten it.
Editor's note: Brave Bison, which acquired Mark Ritson's MiniMBA in 2025, owns about 28% of System1 and sought to acquire the rest this year.
via Adweek (Source)
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in marketing, advertising, marketing technology, media, SEO and search at Marketing Herald.
387 articles
More on the wire
- Amazon Swaps Product Showcase for Emotion in Holiday Spot 'Joy Delivered'
- Arnold Schwarzenegger Plays Santa in Amazon's Second Holiday Ad of the Season
- Dame Kristin Scott Thomas Stars as Gloria in John Lewis' 20th Christmas Campaign
- Christmas Ads Still Belong to Celebrities, Not Creators
- Disney’s Three-Minute 2025 Holiday Film Features an Invisible Horse