MH-6137MarTech & AI
AI Marketers Aim for 'A Couple Notches Above Apathy' as Public Turns
With 90% of online AI talk carrying an 'ick' factor, agencies like Mother, Dentsu and VML say the realistic goal for AI campaigns is 'a couple notches above apathy.'
Wire notes
- Mother LA strategist Nika Rastakhiz estimates at least 90% of online AI conversation carries an 'ick' quality, with only about 10% practical in tone.
- Mother created Anthropic's Super Bowl campaign attacking OpenAI's decision to insert ads into its chatbot earlier this year.
- A Mother campaign repositioning an unnamed AI brand with negative press is expected within the next couple of weeks.
- Dentsu research found older consumers treat AI as a search-engine replacement, younger ones seek emotional support, and women trust AI less than men across use cases.
- VML's Howard Laubscher predicts AI brands will 'self-regulate' preemptively, comparing it to JetBlue's 2007 customer bill of rights.

At least 90% of online conversation about AI carries an "ick" quality, according to Nika Rastakhiz, head of strategy at Mother LA — and that number is reshaping how agencies advertise the technology. The realistic goal for AI campaigns, she told Marketing Brew, is "a couple notches above apathy." Rastakhiz added: "I know [that] doesn't sound like the most aspirational thing of all time."
The backdrop is measurable public skepticism. Gallup polling and an ABC News/Ipsos survey show Americans broadly cool toward AI, with concerns concentrated on data centers, job threats and other potential harms. Recent election results and news cycles about AI-triggered extinction risks have deepened the mood. Agencies must now acknowledge those fears while still selling AI products — without appearing to pander, Rastakhiz said. "From a strategy perspective, and particularly from a communication perspective, [it's] a new frontier of how to communicate," she said. "There's quite a lot of nuance."
How Mother and Dentsu are playing it
Mother created Anthropic's Super Bowl campaign, which attacked chief rival OpenAI's move earlier this year to insert ads into its chatbot. Within the next couple of weeks, Rastakhiz said, the agency will launch a campaign repositioning an AI brand she declined to name, one that has drawn "quite a lot of negative sentiment in the press." Her strategy: focus on surprising but "undeniable use cases," such as an AI tool that helps rescue stray dogs. "When it comes to talking to people who haven't completely slammed the door shut on AI…how do we actually just keep the door ajar and have them feel this feeling of, 'OK, that's not bad. I'll give you that,'" she said. "It's like neutrality into slight hints of positivity."
Dentsu's global chief strategy officer, Patricia McDonald, warned that the default tech-advertiser pitch — AI relieving tedious life tasks — can backfire. People do not necessarily want AI to take holiday shopping off their plate. "Just because you build it doesn't mean people want it or are ready for it or are going to jump on it," McDonald said. "There's a whole element of 'one person's friction is another person's fun,' or another person's moment of human connection." Her advice to brands: be "mindful [that] the role you play in people's lives is probably not as all-encompassing as you think it is."
Should brands say 'AI' at all?
Howard Laubscher, chief strategy officer at VML Kansas City, said consumers accept AI uses built on logic and reasoning more readily than those built on empathy and creativity. Messaging, he argued, should sell the outcome and drop the buzzwords entirely. "The general term 'AI'—just its connotation—is completely negative," Laubscher said. "It's kind of like saying the word 'digital.' I think everything's a little bit 'agentic' these days…Much like we went through the era of the 'digital' age, and then the 'social' age, eventually those words drop, and it becomes about what's actually being done for you."
What the sentiment data shows
Mother tracks brand and topic sentiment through an internal dashboard called Motherboard. It finds "very small pockets" of wildly positive feeling; the rest runs neutral to negative. Negativity clusters around AI appearing where consumers think it does not belong, and around AI making dumb mistakes, Rastakhiz said. Dentsu's research adds demographic texture: older people treat AI as a search-engine replacement, younger consumers turn to it for "emotional support," and women are less trusting than men in delegating tasks to AI across all use cases. Regional differences matter too. "You get some really interesting local nuances. In some cases, that's about security. In some markets, it's more about [wanting] messaging to feel very warm and very personalized," McDonald said.
Naming the elephant in the room
Super Bowl advertisers this year often used humor to defuse AI worries, McDonald noted. "If you sort of name the elephant in the room and have some fun and some playfulness with it, that's interesting," she said. Rastakhiz cautioned that over-leaning on AI's "humanity" has already become trope-y: "If you are very pro-AI, you start to alienate quite a lot of people, and then on the opposite end, if you're incredibly apologetic…then that doesn't come across as a confident brand whatsoever." Laubscher predicts more AI brands will loudly "self-regulate" ahead of policy, comparing the move to JetBlue's 2007 "customer bill of rights": "You'll have leaders that are trying to be the good guys in the space and be the first to move."
via news.gallup.com (Original)
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in marketing, advertising, marketing technology, media, SEO and search at Marketing Herald.
360 articles
More on the wire
- AI Agents Won't Fix Bad Audience Data, They'll Amplify It
- 89% of U.S. Adults Worry About AI — and 55% Use It Weekly Anyway
- A School District Beat Big Tech to Publishing an AI Accountability Document
- CMOs Spend 15.3% of Budgets on AI, but Only 30% Can Scale It
- Attribution Should Run Your AI, Not the Other Way Around