WSJ Cuts Planning Time 75% With AI — and Wins More Million-Dollar Deals

WSJ's AI planning tool cuts RFP turnaround from five hours to one, and win rates on million-dollar pitches rose five points, says CRO Josh Stinchcomb.

Wire notes

  • Win rate on million-dollar-plus RFPs rose five percentage points after time savings were redeployed, per CRO Josh Stinchcomb.
  • An AI tool in testing builds media plans in about an hour, versus four or five hours manually.
  • Wider rollout of the planning tool is planned for early next year.
  • Less than 5% of the Journal's digital ad revenue is programmatic.
  • WSJ Intelligence allows branded content to be 'facilitated' by AI tools 'but not written by them.'
Putting AI To Work At WSJ
PhotoPutting AI To Work At WSJ — RonaldCandonga / pixabay

The Wall Street Journal's win rate on million-dollar-plus RFPs (requests for proposals) has risen five percentage points since AI reclaimed planners' time for bigger pitches, according to global Chief Revenue Officer Josh Stinchcomb.

Speaking on AdExchanger Talks, Stinchcomb laid out how AI has spread through the Journal's ad sales operation — not through flashy generative projects, but by automating work nobody wanted in the first place.

What is AI actually doing at the Journal?

The sales team now uses an internal AI-powered search tool that digs up stats buried in old email threads and Slack channels before meetings. It can also recap a seller's last conversation with a prospect, so they walk in knowing exactly where the discussion left off.

"It's really helpful for pulling from the information we have available to ourselves but isn't always at our fingertips," Stinchcomb says. "That's been a great time-saver."

A second tool serves digital operations. It checks line items against ad creative and IOs (insertion orders, the contracts governing ad placements) and takes campaign screenshots — a task Stinchcomb calls "laborious and really unfun." The payoff: fewer botched campaign launches and less inventory lost to make-goods (free ad space given to advertisers when a campaign underdelivers).

In short: the boring tasks are going to machines, and the error costs are falling.

Where is the bigger bet placed?

Media planning. Today, a planner needs four or five hours to turn an RFP into a plan, largely because inventory must be checked across multiple systems. The Journal is testing a tool that reads RFPs, examines past campaigns for similar audiences and builds a recommended plan in about an hour.

With the team producing thousands of plans a year, that compression frees substantial capacity. Stinchcomb says the saved time is being redeployed toward larger million-dollar-plus RFPs — the deals where the five-point win-rate gain occurred.

A wider rollout of the planning tool is planned for early next year.

"Bringing it all together is a great strategy," Stinchcomb says. "It's an efficient way to bring in chunks of revenue."

The caveat sits inside the claim: the win-rate improvement is attributed to redeployed effort, not to the tool writing winning plans itself. Stinchcomb does not say how much of the gain tests will preserve at scale.

Where does the Journal draw the line?

Branded content. WSJ Intelligence, the Journal's custom content studio, follows the newsroom's lead on what AI may touch. The work might be "facilitated by these tools," Stinchcomb says, "but not written by them."

His reasoning is commercial, not sentimental. "AI is great at sort of rehashing what's out there," he says. "It's not necessarily great at breaking news, as it were, or bringing a fresher perspective."

Branded content competes with everything else fighting for a reader's attention. If it is boring or derivative, "[people] don't read it, and I'm not getting paid."

The line is clear: efficiency tools get rolled out; authorship stays human — because readers, not vendors, punish derivative output.

What else did Stinchcomb reveal?

  • Less than 5% of the Journal's digital ad revenue is programmatic (automated ad buying through open exchanges).
  • He addressed how WSJ Intelligence keeps its custom research credible.
  • He described News Corp's "woo and sue" approach to AI licensing deals — negotiating first, litigating when necessary.
  • And he disclosed a past life as the singer in a "tragic emo-style" high school band.

The strategy, stripped of noise: automate the four-hour tasks, reinvest the hours in the million-dollar ones, and keep the bylines human. Early next year's wider rollout will show whether the five-point win-rate gain survives contact with scale.

via adweek.com (Original)

Filed under

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in marketing, advertising, marketing technology, media, SEO and search at Marketing Herald.

346 articles

More on the wire

« Previous articleNext article »