Target’s 5.6% sales growth masks gains in food, weakness in fashion
Target’s 5.6% third-quarter comparable-sales growth was traffic-led, but apparel and home remain weak as food and beauty outpace the wider business under CEO Michael Fiddelke.
Wire notes
- Target’s comparable sales rose 5.6% in the third quarter, with comparable traffic up 5%.
- Stacked against 2024, comparable sales grew 2.9%, up from 1.9% in the second quarter.
- Food and beverage sales grew nearly 7% year over year; beauty rose more than 9% as Target added 90 brands.
- Target introduced about 2,000 food items and moved 600 stores out of the Ulta shop-in-shop setup.
- Michael Fiddelke became CEO in February; Gildenberg called next year the decisive test.
By Elena Vasquez
Target reported third-quarter comparable sales (like-for-like sales) growth of 5.6% on Wednesday, powered by a 5% increase in comparable store traffic.
CEO Michael Fiddelke has led Target since February. Modern Retail said the results gave investors confidence that the retailer was finding its footing. Target also reported food and beverage sales growth of nearly 7% year over year. Beauty sales rose more than 9%.
What does Target’s 5.6% growth actually show?
Bryan Gildenberg, founder and CEO of Confluencer Commerce and longtime retail consultant, described 2025 as a really bad year. When stacked against 2024, Target’s comparable sales grew 2.9%, up from 1.9% in the second quarter, Gildenberg said.
He added: “That’s better and not bad. But in an inflationary environment, 2.9% comps aren’t going to put you in the retail hall of fame.”
Target introduced 90 new brands while developing Target Beauty Studio after its Ulta shop-in-shop (store-within-a-store) era. Gildenberg attributed the third-quarter increase chiefly to food-driven traffic, while Target reported food and beverage sales growth of nearly 7% year over year and beauty growth above 9%.
The traffic gain does not prove that spending baskets grew; Gildenberg said shoppers were visiting more often, though not necessarily spending more per trip.
Why is food working faster than apparel?
Gildenberg said: “In their journey to fix things, Target seems to have fixed food a little bit faster than they have fixed apparel.” Gildenberg’s diagnosis was more frequent trips, though not necessarily bigger baskets.
Target’s food proposition now fits its brand, Gildenberg said. The problem arises when Target confuses shoppers or fails to deliver its brand promise, Gildenberg said. In Gildenberg’s assessment, food now expresses the classic expect more, pay less promise through a more expect different assortment.
Target moved beyond a conventional grocery set toward newer, more innovative products and introduced about 2,000 food items in the latest quarter, Gildenberg said. Gildenberg praised Good & Gather, Target’s private-label range (goods sold under a retailer’s own brand), for packaging basic commodities and securing better margins for Target. Gildenberg said consumers were rewarding the clearer proposition.
Cara Sylvester, Target’s executive vice president and chief merchandising officer, acknowledged fashion and home struggles. Sylvester described apparel’s challenges as more significant and the assortment and value proposition as too complex. Target cited inconsistencies across fit, fabric and quality. According to Sylvester, the company changed leadership in apparel, reduced style counts and cut prices on hundreds of items.
Who does Target actually face in grocery?
Gildenberg said Target competes with everybody because everybody sells food, but Walmart is not its primary rival across much of its footprint. An overwhelming percentage of Target’s business comes from states where Walmart has less dense saturation, while California represents about a quarter of Target’s business, Gildenberg said. Gildenberg said Walmart is not a direct competitor in California.
Gildenberg identified Kroger and Albertsons chains as the main regional grocery competition in California, Florida and Texas, with Walmart a secondary rival, particularly in Texas.
Costco is another close competitor in customer overlap, but Gildenberg did not argue that Target beats Costco in food. Gildenberg recommends that Target complement a Costco trip with distinctive brands Costco may not carry, rather than become a smaller, slightly more expensive Walmart.
Costco and Trader Joe’s form a symbiotic, mutually reinforcing retail relationship, Gildenberg said, because each grows faster when the other gives shoppers another reason to visit. Target faces a temptation to use frequent food purchases as a traffic driver for apparel because shoppers buy food more often than T-shirts, Gildenberg said. Gildenberg warned that this strategy requires Target to become a completely different retailer.
Can the food reset keep working?
A one-time reset creates a more visceral reaction than incremental changes, Gildenberg said. Being known for new products gives shoppers a mission and a treasure hunt, a proposition that Gildenberg said Costco, Aldi and TJ Maxx already execute well.
Target can win in grocery by getting mothers to raise their heads from the shopping list and look around, Gildenberg said. Gildenberg’s answer made sustainability depend on that discovery habit, not footfall alone.
Why is Target’s beauty business accelerating?
Target said beauty sales rose more than 9% as it introduced 90 new brands while developing Beauty Studio after the Ulta shop-in-shop era.
Gildenberg said Target has moved 600 stores out of the Ulta setup, creating more space to define beauty as a destination and more freedom to carry products the former arrangement restricted. The overlap had become awkward because Target and Ulta were too similar, Gildenberg said. Gildenberg compared the pairing to playing an F and an F-sharp together on a piano.
Target’s reset beauty set leans heavily toward Korean brands popular on TikTok rather than more Maybelline-type brands, Gildenberg said. Gildenberg warned that some distinctive products will not sell and that Target must rotate effectively. Rotational merchandising, meaning frequent changes to the product mix, suits Target better than repeating the same items, Gildenberg said, because Target remains a fashion retailer.
What must change under Michael Fiddelke?
Gildenberg called next year the tell and said Target handled the earnings call well by owning its remaining shortfalls. Gildenberg described home as a multi-year journey requiring a strategy. Target has not reinvented its home approach since Home Goods took that retail lane, Gildenberg said. Gildenberg called Home Goods a major competitive problem for Target.
Women’s apparel still needs work, Gildenberg said. Gildenberg praised Target’s collaboration with Olivia Culpo, Picolette for kids, as smart positioning and the most encouraging apparel move in the quarter. Dupe culture (lower-priced imitations of established styles) now shapes pay-less fashion, Gildenberg said. Quince, notably, has become a business worth more than $1 billion, Gildenberg said.
Target must define its position among fast fashion, dupe fashion and thrifted fashion, according to Gildenberg. Gildenberg said Picolette offered better-styled Quince, using Quince price points while adding more stylistic detail and fashion. Next year’s comparable sales, basket size (spending per trip) and execution in apparel and home will test whether Fiddelke can convert traffic-led food gains into durable performance, Gildenberg said.
via Modern Retail (Source)
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in marketing, advertising, marketing technology, media, SEO and search at Marketing Herald.
383 articles