Good comms work can hide a broken function, consultants warn

Strong output at a Fortune 500 healthcare comms team concealed unclear priorities and planning that 'lived in people's heads,' United Minds and Weber Shandwick consultants write.

Wire notes

  • A Fortune 500 healthcare company's comms team delivered strong work while its operating model had unclear priorities and planning that 'lived in people's heads'
  • Authors Ellyn Michalak (United Minds) and Perri Mayer (Weber Shandwick) identify five behaviors that indicate a healthy comms function
  • AI can make an unhealthy function look productive longer by raising output without fixing prioritization or coordination, the authors warn
  • One cited team helped leaders reformulate a food dye product before public pressure built by raising the issue early
The most dangerous sign of an unhealthy comms function? Good work.
PhotoThe most dangerous sign of an unhealthy comms function? Good work. — andibreit / pixabay

A Fortune 500 healthcare company's communications team delivered strong work under pressure while its operating model quietly failed, according to two consultants who say output is the most misleading measure of a comms function's health.

Ellyn Michalak, senior principal at United Minds, and Perri Mayer, senior vice president at Weber Shandwick, writing in PR Daily, describe an engagement where the work was strong and leaders got what they needed. Closer inspection revealed unclear priorities, inconsistent processes and cross-functional planning that "lived in people's heads."

Work moved because experienced leaders knew whom to call and how to route around the system. "Good work had not disproved dysfunction. It had concealed it," the authors write. Once they saw that, the engagement shifted to clarifying processes, prioritizing projects tied to business results and deciding what to stop.

For chief communications officers (CCOs), the pair argue, energy spent compensating for a weak system cannot be spent challenging thinking, anticipating what comes next or shaping decisions. They propose five diagnostic behaviors, each paired with a self-assessment question.

What should CCOs measure besides output?

1. Shaping decisions while leaders still have choices. Nearly every function aspires to be a strategic partner; far fewer can point to a business decision that changed because communications was involved. The distinction is timing: once a decision is made, communications explains or defends it. The authors cite a communications leader who saw a widely used food dye becoming a public flashpoint and raised it early, helping leaders reformulate before pressure built. Their test: what recent business decision changed because communications was involved before it was finalized?

2. Deciding what not to do. Most communications leaders claim a capacity problem. The deeper problem, the authors argue, is that nobody has decided what the function should not do. Legacy reports continue, channels stay active, every request becomes urgent — and a full pipeline can look like relevance when it actually means nobody is steering. Their test: what have we deliberately stopped doing, and where did that capacity go?

3. Not relying on heroes. Collaboration requires shared priorities and clear decision rights, so that measurement informs planning and media and storytelling teams connect by design. "Heroic dot connectors" who unstick projects with carefully placed phone calls are invaluable — but also a warning sign. If cross-team work stalls without them, the authors write, "You simply have one person manually holding it together." Their test: does critical work bring together measurement, media and storytelling by design, or only when a well-connected person intervenes?

4. Connecting signals others see separately. Communications hears from more audiences than almost any function, yet signals sit siloed across employee feedback, media coverage, stakeholder conversations and channel data. An employee concern may look isolated until the same tension surfaces in customer questions and media interest. The value is not another report, the authors write, but helping leaders see what is changing while there is still time to respond. Their test: what pattern has communications spotted by connecting separate signals?

5. Turning experiments into shared capabilities. AI (artificial intelligence tools that generate or speed up content work) can make an unhealthy function look productive for longer by increasing output without improving how work is prioritized, coordinated or scaled. "The risk is that a few AI enthusiasts get faster while the function itself stays the same," the authors write. Strong functions build successful use cases into workflows, establish guardrails, train others and measure improvement. A faster first draft for one person is helpful, but it is not transformation. Their test: which recent experiment became a repeatable capability across the function?

Why the stakes rise with AI

The authors close with a caveat that cuts against current industry enthusiasm: as AI makes content faster and cheaper, output will say even less about a function's health. In their framing, the biggest cost of an unhealthy function is not wasted time or burnout — "It's the strategic work that never happens because your most talented people are too busy keeping the system running."

The prescription is blunt: ask the five questions regularly, because the answers show whether the system is getting stronger or people are simply getting better at compensating for it. The problem, they write, is when extraordinary effort becomes the everyday way of working.

via ragan.com (Original)

Filed under

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in marketing, advertising, marketing technology, media, SEO and search at Marketing Herald.

354 articles

More on the wire

« Previous article