MH-2670Social Media
Fake Instagram Profiles Multiply in Brazil, Throwing Brand Metrics Off Track
Brazil has up to 154.8 million active Instagram accounts, and users increasingly run fake profiles to stalk and research anonymously — distorting the audience data brands rely on.
Wire notes
- Brazil has between 141 million and 154.8 million active Instagram accounts, per platform data
- FGV professor Elis Monteiro says fake profiles distort brand advertising by inflating follower volume without representing real consumers
- Users interviewed run one or two anonymous accounts each for stalking, competitor tracking and topic research
- Psychologist Carla Cavalheiro warns hyperfocus can turn 15 planned minutes of browsing into hours

Brazil holds between 141 million and 154.8 million active Instagram accounts, according to recent figures from the platform itself — and nobody, including Instagram, knows how many belong to the same person.
A growing share of those accounts are fakes, created by ordinary users to browse anonymously, stalk acquaintances and keep their main feeds clean. The practice has consequences well beyond etiquette: FGV digital marketing professor Elis Monteiro says fake profiles "disorient" the advertising operations of a large share of brands, because "despite making up volume in the follower base, they do not represent the real consumer."
Why are users building second accounts?
Public relations professional Camila Battaglia, 31, from Rio de Janeiro, created hers in mid-last year. While furnishing a new home, she researched furniture and design references until her feed turned into a single-topic architecture and construction network. Her solution was a separate account used purely for searches, fed with no personal content.
"I trained the algorithm of this new page by following and interacting with profiles that talked only about décor, interior design and furniture," she said. "It was good, because I didn't mix the topics I research into my personal network."
Veterinarian Rayna Dias, 25, built a fake profile for a different reason: to gossip about other people's lives. She analyses "everything on 'off' mode." "I use this other account a lot. When I fight with my boyfriend, for example, and he excludes me, I log in to see what he's doing through his friends' stories," she said.
Commercial analyst Laryssa Gomes, 37, runs two fake accounts with distinct jobs. The first lets her follow competitors of her employer without disturbing her personal Instagram algorithm. The second exists to stalk acquaintances undetected. "I like to spy and try to discover something new, watching the stories of someone I don't have much contact with, without going through the embarrassment of them noticing I stopped by," she said.
Who else hides behind anonymous handles?
Celebrities and executives in leadership roles routinely use anonymous profiles to protect their privacy while browsing, according to Monteiro. "They are people who don't want to be left out of conversations, who want to comment on certain subjects, but fear exposure. The profile serves as a kind of protective shield in cases where the courage to speak publicly is lacking," she said.
Carla Cavalheiro, a psychologist at the Institute of Psychiatry of the Hospital das Clínicas, frames gossip and curiosity about others' lives as "ancestral and primitive" practices. The problem, she argues, is that big tech firms quickly recognised this desire as something that engages users while simultaneously isolating them.
"We need to remember that everything we post on social media is an often-edited excerpt, something deleterious to the construction of someone's identity, a part of a whole," Cavalheiro said. "You end up with a hijacking of what could be a conversation to get to know the other person better, or even to align agreements in relationships."
On theme-based profile splitting, she warns against hyperfocus and the time distortion social networks produce: "There are people who plan to browse for 15 minutes, and when they notice, hours have passed immersed in the phone."
For brands, the takeaway is blunt: follower counts inflated by secondary and anonymous accounts measure curiosity, not customers. In an era of permanent exposure, hiding has itself become part of being connected — and every hidden account is one more data point advertisers cannot reliably see.
via oglobo.com (Source)
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in marketing, advertising, marketing technology, media, SEO and search at Marketing Herald.
360 articles
More on the wire
- A Fake Photo of Mia Goth Got 500,000 Likes. Meta Acted Only After a Reporter Called
- Influencers Ask Followers for Advice to Keep Influence, Study Finds
- U.S. Bank Cut Research Time in Half With Synthetic Personas
- Instagram activity linked to two distinct forms of loneliness
- Creator Mindset Beats Influencer Status, Shira Lazar Tells Comms Pros