97% Retention: How Independent Agencies Engineer Culture Past 100 Staff

Mischief hit 97% staff and client retention while tripling headcount. Mother, Rethink and Erich & Kallman show how independents codify taste so standards survive the founders' absence.

Wire notes

  • Mischief grew from six employees to more than 100, hiring 24 in 2024 alone, with 97% staff and client retention.
  • Rethink reports 94% client retention and an average client relationship of seven years.
  • Erich & Kallman won Chick-fil-A from five rival agencies in 2017 after the chain left The Richards Group after 22 years.
  • Adweek named Rethink Independent Agency of the Year in December 2025 as it marked 25 years.
  • Mother replaced its motto 'Make Our Mothers Proud' with the global operating system 'Make Our Children Proud'.
Inside The Creative Cultures Independent Founders Built To Last
PhotoInside The Creative Cultures Independent Founders Built To Last — StartupStockPhotos / pixabay

By Tom Whitfield

Mischief started with six full-time employees. By the end of 2024 it employed more than 100, having hired 24 people in a single year, and both its staff retention and client retention sat at 97 percent — the year Adweek named it Midsize Agency of the Year.

The number matters because it captures the problem every independent founder eventually faces. Culture built when everyone sat within earshot of the founders starts to strain once the agency passes its 50th, 75th and 100th hire. The founders cannot be in every review. Something has to do their job when they are not in the room. The independents that keep their standards through growth tend to answer that question mechanically: who sees the work, what leaves the building, which clients get in, and who runs the place next.

Who sits around the table at Mother?

Mother has answered the first question for decades. "We all sit around the table, we all take the brief, we don't have account people," Peter Robertson, one of the London agency's longest-serving creative leaders, said in a Creative Salon interview. He joined Mother roughly 20 years ago from New Zealand with his creative partner Susan Hosking. Early reviews happened on a round sofa that, by their account, is still upstairs.

Robertson described the agency plainly: Mother has "always broken the rules," and a good share of those broken rules were later adopted by the rest of the industry. He and Hosking also described something harder to codify — "an innate kindness about Mother," where nobody climbs by stepping on colleagues.

Co-founder Robert Saville used the same interview to attack the industry's reputation. "Our industry is often represented by self-serving egotists," he said. In his telling, Robertson and Hosking are the opposite.

Mother has since formalized its values into an operating system called Make Our Children Proud, which Robertson and Hosking helped design and which replaced the earlier motto Make Our Mothers Proud. It accounts for the agency's effect on its people, the industry and the planet, and Mother has adopted it globally. Hosking attached one condition: it only works if every office adopts it and helps shape it. A founder's taste cannot be photocopied. It has to be rebuilt by the people in each new room.

What leaves the building at Rethink?

Rethink, based in Toronto, turned 25 in 2025 and was named Adweek's Independent Agency of the Year that December. It now runs offices in Toronto, Vancouver, Montreal and New York. Its founders stepped aside in 2020, when the business converted from a corporation into a limited partnership run by a group of partners — usually the moment founder-led culture starts to drift.

Rethink's answer was to write the taste down. Every piece of work passes through a review called CRAFT, asking whether it is clear, relevant, achievable, fresh, true and shareable. The founders' hallway questions still get asked after the founders are gone.

Global chief creative officer Aaron Starkman put the standard in plain terms to LBB. "If anything goes out the door that smells off-brand for our client partners, it's definitely off brand for Rethink," he said. He credited the agency's creative retention to the fact that "they know their ambitious ideas aren't going to get murdered by ultra-safe account people." With clients, the same directness applies: "Honesty is a gift of clarity," he said, and "'Just say the thing!' is a thing we say."

Starkman described a "go then grow" habit — taking ideas to market with minimal investment before scaling — a small-company instinct Rethink kept as it added offices. Adweek's 2025 profile counted 20 new creative hires across North America. "We genuinely try to prioritize people, product and profit, in that order," Starkman said. Global chief strategy officer and partner Sean McDonald went shorter: "Growth isn't our goal. Good is our goal."

Rethink aims to keep half its staff in creative roles and reports 94 percent client retention, with the average client relationship lasting seven years. Clients appear to notice the culture as much as the staff do.

Who gets in the door at Mischief?

Culture is also who the agency agrees to work for. Mischief, which operates as part of the Canadian agency No Fixed Address, screens clients openly: it looks for brands that are intelligent, nice, aware of their own creative process and willing to pay fairly, according to Adweek.

"We want to make sure that we are the right agency for them versus trying to be something we're not," said Kerry McKibbin, Mischief's partner and president. Every bad-fit client teaches the staff that standards are negotiable; turning one down teaches the opposite. Co-founder and chief creative officer Greg Hahn framed the mission as "create a stir and a conversation" — a shop with that goal cannot afford many clients who want neither.

Who gets to decide at Erich & Kallman?

Erich & Kallman, a San Francisco independent, built part of its pitch around size. Not long after opening it won Chick-fil-A from five rival agencies, after the chain ended a 22-year relationship with The Richards Group, as the American Marketing Association's magazine reported in 2017. Its leaders reject the word "small," though. "We're smaller, but we're not small," chief marketing officer Stephen Larkin told LBB in 2024.

The agency protects culture through autonomy. Kati Haberstock, executive head of production, described a team where "people feel free to work in a way where they don't feel like they have to come and ask for approval." Most agencies add layers and sign-offs as they grow; every extra layer gives an idea another chance to die quietly. Autonomy only works when people already share the standards — which is why the other answers come first. Founder and chief creative officer Eric Kallman joked that their lives "are in shambles outside of Erich & Kallman," but "man, do we really crush the work!"

What the founders say themselves

For all the systems, founders describe the experience personally. Mark Fitzloff, who started the Portland independent Opinionated in 2017 after nearly two decades of demanding client work, wrote on his own site: "Nothing prepares you for the experience of running your own company." The line covers the moment a founder realizes culture cannot depend on being in every meeting.

The four agencies found different answers. Mother changed who sits at the table; Rethink wrote its taste into a review process; Mischief decided who gets in the door; Erich & Kallman cut the number of doors an idea must pass through. What they share is the assumption that culture does not take care of itself as a company grows — someone builds it on purpose, usually before it is obviously needed.

Rethink's Marie Lunny, partner and managing director of its Toronto office, stated the planning horizon. "It matters to us who will be running this agency in five or 10 years," she told Adweek. For an independent, that may be the only culture question that counts.

via hometownstation.com (Source)

Filed under

Share this article:

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in marketing, advertising, marketing technology, media, SEO and search at Marketing Herald.

430 articles

More on the wire

« Previous articleNext article »