Marc Benioff Declares 'Goodbye SEO' — Salesforce's Own SEO Guide Says Otherwise

Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff posted "Goodbye SEO" on Nov. 18 to promote Palmata, while Salesforce's own Sept. 11 guide states SEO "is still the foundation" — and SEO practitioners agree.

Wire notes

  • Marc Benioff posted "Goodbye SEO" on X on Nov. 18, promoting Salesforce's Palmata tool.
  • Salesforce's own guide, published Sept. 11, states SEO "is still the foundation."
  • Contentful introduced Palmata in June; Salesforce's acquisition of Contentful closed Sept. 1.
  • Palmata is standalone and also built into Marketing Cloud by Salesforce, per its FAQ.
  • Salesforce's guide advises tracking both organic metrics and AI citation counts.
Salesforce CEO Says ‘Goodbye SEO.’ Salesforce’s SEO Guide Disagrees
PhotoSalesforce CEO Says ‘Goodbye SEO.’ Salesforce’s SEO Guide Disagrees — DiggityMarketing / pixabay

Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff posted "Goodbye SEO" on X on Nov. 18, and his own company's published guidance contradicts him within one click.

Benioff was promoting Palmata, an AI-based tool that tracks how visible a company is in AI answers. In his post, he argued that customers "aren't searching anymore" and instead ask Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini and other AI assistants which brands they should purchase. His post states: "No click. No referral. Nothing in your analytics." It then pitches Palmata as a tool that monitors what AI assistants say about a business, recommends changes, and simulates the effect of those changes before publication.

Several SEO professionals countered the claims in quote posts and replies. But the sharpest rebuttal sits on Salesforce's own pages.

What does Salesforce's own documentation say?

A Salesforce guide to SEO and AEO — answer engine optimization — states that SEO "isn't going away" and that "SEO is still the foundation." Graham Hardt, whose byline lists him as SEO Senior Director, wrote the guide for new businesses, and Salesforce published it on Sept. 11. Palmata's product page links to the guide directly from its FAQ.

Palmata itself arrived earlier. Contentful introduced the tool in June, and it became part of Salesforce when the acquisition of Contentful closed on Sept. 1. The launch article, written by Jason McGhee, head of product and engineering for Palmata, said SEO gave organizations "a practical framework for improving visibility" and added: "That work remains essential."

In other words, the team that built the product Benioff is promoting has publicly framed SEO as essential work, not a dying discipline.

How did SEO professionals respond?

Practitioners pushed back on the post across quote posts and replies:

  • Aleyda Solis, an SEO and AI search consultant who founded Orainti, wrote that AI search "relies on many of the same fundamentals as SEO." Her post continues: "AI search optimization goes beyond traditional SEO, but it certainly doesn't replace it." She also noted that measuring AI search visibility matters, "but monitoring what AI platforms say about your brand and actually improving your visibility, recommendations and business outcomes are very different things."
  • Pedro Dias, a technical SEO product manager and former Google employee, wrote that SEO "was never a topic that attracted the interest of decision makers." His post adds: "SEO isn't traffic. It never has been."
  • Lily Ray, founder of Algorythmic, replied to Benioff: "This gold rush already happened and the market is already oversaturated."
  • Growth advisor Eli Schwartz wrote that "there's yet another AEO tool in the mix."

What does this change for marketing buyers?

When a marketing executive reads Benioff's post, Salesforce's own guide supplies the answer: SEO and AEO are "two visibility layers for the same audience." The guide makes the case that new businesses should keep SEO in their plans alongside any AI visibility tool, including Palmata.

According to Palmata's FAQ, the tool is standalone and also built into Marketing Cloud by Salesforce. For teams weighing such tools, the guide's instruction is to track "both sets of metrics" — organic traffic and rankings on one side, and AI citation counts on the other. The practical takeaway for buyers: treat AI visibility monitoring as an addition to the measurement stack, not a replacement for the metrics already on the dashboard.

via searchenginejournal.com (Source)

Filed under

Share this article:

More from Priya Raman

Priya Raman

Show full bio

Correspondent covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in marketing, advertising, marketing technology, media, SEO and search at Marketing Herald.

383 articles

More on the wire

« Previous articleNext article »