Erewhon's $749 Thanksgiving Feast Tests the Luxury Grocery Ceiling

Erewhon's $749 pre-order Thanksgiving feast works out to $74.90 per person, while the average meal for 10 costs $58.63. Southern California grocers now span $89.99 to $749 on ready-made dinners.

Wire notes

  • Erewhon's 'ultimate organic feast' costs $749 and serves 8 to 10 people, about $74.90 per person.
  • The average Thanksgiving meal for 10 costs $58.63, up 6.3% from 2025, per the American Farm Bureau Federation.
  • Ready-made Southern California options range from Vallarta's $89.99 meal to Whole Foods' $599.99 feast for 12.
  • Economists say ready-made meals always cost more due to labor, packaging and convenience.
  • Erewhon's price drew online mockery, including creator Brandon Hau calling it 'a social experiment.'
Erewhon is offering ‘ultimate organic’ Thanksgiving feast. Its price tag? Oh so Erewhon
PhotoErewhon is offering ‘ultimate organic’ Thanksgiving feast. Its price tag? Oh so Erewhon — HeartlandMom / pixabay

Erewhon is selling a pre-order "ultimate organic feast" for $749, roughly $74.90 per person for 8 to 10 guests — nearly thirteen times the $58.63 the American Farm Bureau Federation says an average Thanksgiving meal for 10 now costs. The Los Angeles organic grocer, known for gourmet food, a devoted following and steep prices, released the meal amid a holiday season that exposes a widening gap in how Americans buy the same dinner.

The Farm Bureau's 41st annual Thanksgiving dinner survey put the average cost of serving 10 people at $58.63, up 6.3% compared to 2025. Researchers weighted a complete menu including a 16-pound turkey, whole milk, carrots, celery, cranberries, cubed stuffing, dinner rolls, frozen green peas, sweet potatoes, pumpkin pie mix, frozen pie crusts, heavy whipping cream, ham, frozen green beans and russet potatoes.

The ready-made market splits sharply from that baseline. Southern California grocers are selling fully cooked feasts at price points that range from a budget tier to a luxury tier.

  • Vallarta Supermarkets: $89.99 for six to eight people, about $11.24 a plate. The menu includes a butterball turkey, creamy mashed potatoes, homestyle gravy, stuffing and cranberry orange relish.
  • Ralphs: $95 for six to eight people, $11.87 each. A bone-in turkey comes with Kroger-brand sides including homestyle stuffing, green bean casserole, maple pecan mashed sweet potatoes, cranberry sauce, mashed potatoes and classic gravy.
  • Sprouts: $129.99 for six, $21.66 per person, featuring an organic turkey, organic sourdough stuffing, Yukon gold mashed potatoes, turkey gravy and cranberry sauce.
  • Bristol Farms: $279.99 for 8 to 12 guests, $23.33 per person, with an organic turkey, two stuffings, green bean Almondine, roasted Brussels sprouts with Applewood bacon, creamed corn and brioche rolls.
  • Whole Foods Market: a "Thanksgiving Extravaganza for 12" at $599.99, or $49.99 a head, with two entrées — roasted turkey and maple bourbon ham — plus ten sides and two desserts, apple pie and pumpkin pie.
  • Erewhon: the $749 "ultimate organic feast," with a free-range cooked turkey, sourdough and roasted vegetable stuffing, rainbow carrots, Brussels sprouts, garlic mashed potatoes, turkey gravy and a deep-dish pumpkin pie.

What does the price spread signal?

Erewhon's meal drew immediate mockery online. Brandon Hau, a digital creator in Northern California, called the meal a social experiment in an Instagram video. "Erewhon has to be out of their ... minds because what do you mean their Thanksgiving feast is $749," he said. One commenter on his video quipped, "8-10 people in Los Angeles, 4-5 people in the real world." Hau's own verdict: "I don't know who is buying this, but props to you."

Food economists read the meal differently. Ricky Volpe, a professor in the Agribusiness department at Cal Poly San Luis Obispo, said conventional grocers carry a different obligation. "It's incumbent upon them to have food that is at a price point that is affordable for all quintiles of U.S. households in terms of earnings," he said. "Erewhon and Whole Foods are in a different position because of the demographics to which they're appealing." He added: "The Erewhon meal is sort of an interesting anecdote, and it exists because there's a demand for that sort of thing, but that's not in any way reflective of affordability in the United States."

Jeffrey Dorfman, professor of Agricultural and Resource Economics at North Carolina State University, noted that ready-made options always cost more than cooking from scratch because consumers pay for labor, cooking staff, packaging and convenience on top of the food itself. Spending less than $100 on a full meal remains possible, he said — yet some customers splurge anyway. "There are people who do spend hundreds of dollars, maybe even $1,000, if they buy some nice wine and three or four different pies for desserts," Dorfman said.

For grocery marketers, the lesson is segmentation, not excess: the same holiday table now supports an $11.24 plate and a $74.90 plate, and retailers are pricing to their demographics rather than to the average.

via latimes.com (Source)

Filed under

Share this article:

More from Priya Raman

Priya Raman

Show full bio

Correspondent covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in marketing, advertising, marketing technology, media, SEO and search at Marketing Herald.

367 articles

More on the wire

« Previous article